You are currently browsing comments. If you would like to return to the full story, you can read the full entry here: “Learn the History”.
Learn the History
by Nancy Oates on December 18, 2018
• Permalink
Tagged Silent Sam
Posted by Nancy Oates on December 18, 2018
http://chapelhillwatch.com/2018/12/18/learn-the-history/
Previous Post
Shelter From the Storm
Shelter From the Storm
Next Post
Touchstones
Touchstones
Recent Comments
- Nancy Oates on We’re still here
- Deborah Fulghieri on We’re still here
- Pluramus on Greene Tract series continues
- Nancy Oates on Greene Tract series continues
- Nancy Oates on Greene Tract series continues
- Plurimus on Greene Tract series continues
- Plurimus on Greene Tract series continues
- Nancy Oates on Greene Tract series continues
- plurimus on Greene Tract series continues
Blogroll
Categories
- 140 West
- Budget
- Business
- Carolina North
- CH2020
- Committees
- Community life
- Council Members
- County business
- Courts
- Courtyards of Homestead
- COVID-19
- Deer
- Downtown Chapel Hill
- Economic development
- Elections
- Environment
- Ethics
- Food Trucks
- Homeless Shelter
- Housing
- Land Use
- Library
- Lifestyle
- Media
- Museum
- Northside
- Occupy Protests
- Parking
- Police
- Politics
- Public Works
- Roads
- Sanitation workers
- Schools
- Social justice
- Spending
- Taxes
- Technology
- Town staff
- Transportation
- Trees
- UNC
- Uncategorized
- Work and Money
Tag Cloud
123 West Franklin advisory boards affordability American Legion annexation Bicycle Apartments bond referendum BRT Bus ads candidates Carolina Flats cell phones Central West CH2020 Charterwood Community Home Trust comprehensive plan county commissioners county government development Ephesus-Fordham fireworks form-based zoning Franklin Street Friends of Downtown Growth health care Historic District Commission historic districts Holidays Light Rail Obey Creek park-and-ride personalities real estate sales Rogers Road Shortbread Silent Sam students The Edge Timber Hollow towing traffic Trinitas VOEMeta
Plurimus
/ December 19, 2018Pointing fingers over separating white and black history flies in the face of why the Silent Sam statue was offensive to so many in the first place, eh? Like it or not, this statue is part of our shared history and denying it risks the repetition of some pretty awful behavior.
Personally, I think the manner in which the statue was removed, as was the universities refusal to remove it gracefully is worthwhile debate. Regardless of that debate, putting it back would be a supreme insult and a giant step backward for a university that prides itself on a place where “…..students develop a voice for critical thought and the courage to guide change”.
That said, it feels as if we risk missing the “teachable moments” and chances for longer term reconciliation and education that are so often lost in these emotional storms.
If history and education are gifts from one generation to another (….and yes, they go both ways), then the Silent Sam statue belongs in a museum along with a serious discussion of why it is a representation of a failed ideology, and also acknowledgement of the lives that were sacrificed for that failed ideology. This statue should be placed next to statues of people who exposed and ultimately defeated that ideology and explain why. It should be part of the curriculum, not forgotten simply because people don’t like it.
“The most effective way to destroy people is to deny and obliterate their own understanding of their history.” ― George Orwell
Nancy
/ December 21, 2018I agree we need to tell our history lest we forget it, as our current U.S. president has in so many areas. We don’t want to slip back, and human nature being what it is, we must be constantly vigilant. But we can still tell our history, even without the statue. If the statue only serves as a flashpoint for protest, then it needs to be sent off to some place that is not conducive to protests.
Plurimus
/ December 21, 2018I agree. It seems that the conversation is still lost in rage and grief; even now. I think some that want to profit from exploiting those feelings for their own motives, are doing so.
The question at hand must be, how does everyone get to a place of mutual respect and move forward in the 21st century?
CitizenWill
/ December 22, 2018If we’re to be accurate, Silent Sam was erected more to commemorate the KKK and Jim Crow than the advertised purpose of remembering the Confederate dead.
I believe that there’s a place for it on campus – in fact the exact place it currently “stands” with these changes: remove the pedestal, bury Silent Sam in the hole that is left that leaves its eyes an inch or two above-ground.
This will fit the letter of the law and meet those “New Jim Crow” Board of Governors members’ demands.
Burying it also will keep it safe enough from vandalism.
Bonus, it will sit about 6″ below the very anemic memorial to the thousands of slaves who built UNC which sits a few short yards away which is a small acknowledgement of their relative importance.